TravelDiari matches your credit cards to every hotel booking — saving you points you'd otherwise miss.

Card vs Card Comparison

Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant
vs
Hilton Honors Aspire.

Two cards, head-to-head. We break down earning rates, perks, transfer partners, and the actual scenarios where each one wins.

American Express

Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant

Annual fee

$650

Points

Marriott Bonvoy

Signup bonus

95K Bonvoy after $6K in 6 months

Earning highlights

  • →6× at Marriott properties
  • →3× on flights booked direct + dining
  • →2× on everything else

Perks highlights

  • →Free night certificate (85K points value, ~$700+ in peak)
  • →Platinum elite status (15-night equivalent)
  • →$300 dining credit ($25/mo at select restaurants)
  • →Priority Pass lounge access
See in browse cardsarrow_forward

American Express

Hilton Honors Aspire

Annual fee

$550

Points

Hilton Honors

Signup bonus

175K Hilton Honors after $6K in 6 months

Earning highlights

  • →14× at Hilton properties
  • →7× on flights + car rentals + dining
  • →3× on everything else

Perks highlights

  • →Diamond elite status (highest tier — usually 60 nights)
  • →$250 Hilton resort credit
  • →$200 airline incidental credit
  • →Free weekend night every year
  • →Free breakfast for two at Diamond level
See in browse cardsarrow_forward

The verdict

When each card wins.

Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant wins if

Marriott loyalists who stay 5+ Marriott nights a year. FNC alone often offsets the AF.

Weakness: Only useful if Marriott is your hotel chain of choice.

Hilton Honors Aspire wins if

Hilton loyalists. Diamond status + free weekend night routinely offsets $550 AF in one redemption.

Weakness: Hilton points value tops out around 0.5¢ — earn rate compensates but redemption discipline matters.

At a glance

Side-by-side spec sheet.

SpecMarriott Bonvoy BrilliantHilton Honors Aspire
Annual fee$650$550
Points currencyMarriott BonvoyHilton Honors
Top earning rate6× at Marriott properties14× at Hilton properties
Signup bonus95K Bonvoy175K Hilton Honors

Questions

Frequently asked.

Should I get the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant or the Hilton Honors Aspire?

expand_more

Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant wins if marriott loyalists who stay 5+ marriott nights a year. fnc alone often offsets the af. Hilton Honors Aspire wins if hilton loyalists. diamond status + free weekend night routinely offsets $550 af in one redemption.

Can I have both the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant and the Hilton Honors Aspire?

expand_more

Yes — these are issued by different banks (American Express and American Express), so they don't conflict on application rules. Many travelers carry both to stack the strongest benefits from each ecosystem.

Which has the higher annual fee?

expand_more

Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant has the higher annual fee ($650 vs $550). Whether it's worth it depends on which perks you actually use — see the verdict section above.

Are points from Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant more valuable than points from Hilton Honors Aspire?

expand_more

Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant earns Marriott Bonvoy; Hilton Honors Aspire earns Hilton Honors. Different programs have different transfer partners and redemption ceilings — see TravelDiari's points valuation index for current cents-per-point values across both.